There are three types of buyer personas that buy PR firm services: 1) Kindred Spirits 2) Arm’s Length and 3) Been Burned.
Those are the findings from research by Drew McLellan and the Agency Management Institute titled, 2015 Agency Hiring & Firing Insights.
The research, in the form of a PDF report, is freely available for download with registration, which I did to review it and found the data impressive. It’s a worthwhile read for corporate communications and agency heads alike.
The study provides “quantitative attitudinal segmentation research with over 500 marketing decision-makers” with the authority, budget and history of hiring firms. The sample set includes a near-equal mix of both B2B and B2C marketing leaders.
Buyers in the “Kindred Spirits” (31%) persona, “have a favorable opinion of agencies overall. They believe that most genuinely want to understand their customers and their business.”
Don’t miss these related posts:
8 Corporate Communications Tips for Hiring a PR Firm
Survey says PR Best Positioned to Manage Corporate Social Media
6 Ways to Get More from your PR Agency
Those in the “Arm’s Length” (35%) persona “are comfortable setting marketing strategy, and are more likely to say they just need agencies to execute those ideas.”
The “Been Burned” (34%) category tend to be “much more skeptical about agencies” and believe most agencies pretend to know more about their industry and their business than they really do.”
While only 20% of respondents reported having an Agency of Record, the Kindred Spirits are most likely to only have one (59%).
Reasons to Hire and Fire PR Firms
The research also shows that these buyers are very confident in the process of selecting an agency. That process — the RFP — also doesn’t seem to be optional:
“While agencies might prefer to believe that dread of the agency search process discourages organizations from moving to a new agency, most of our respondents feel otherwise. 57% of the group says they “like” or “love” the process of choosing an agency – more than 60% of ‘Kindred Spirits’ and ‘Arm’s Length’ respondents, and 48% of ‘Been Burned’ respondents.”
About half of the respondents or 46% said, “there are factors that automatically disqualify agencies.” Disqualifying factors listed in the report ranged widely from employing staff with criminal histories – to poorly designed websites.
Why do agencies get fired? According to the report:
“The top reasons for firing agencies are that their work didn’t achieve the desired results (46%) and not receiving the appropriate level of attention or responsiveness (31%).”
While I didn’t see it come through the report, there’s one other reason agencies get fired. In all my years across agencies and in corporate communications, a common reason agencies get fired is the team stops bringing ideas to the table.
At that point, PR is nothing more than an order-taker.
Is your PR firm bringing ideas to the table? If they aren’t, contact us today to learn how the Atlanta-based PR agency, Sword and the Script Media, LLC can bring big thinking along with seven possible services including PR and content marketing that deliver results.
If you enjoyed this post, you might also like:
Switching PR Firms: The High Cost of a Steep Learning Curve
Photo credit: Flickr, Matt Deavenport, The Skeptical Face (CC BY-ND 2.0)