Home > PR > Hypothetically, “What If” Questions in PR Lead to Bad News

Hypothetically, “What If” Questions in PR Lead to Bad News

Hypothetically What If Questions Lead to Bad News

Bill Belichick made a questionable decision in a game last Sunday that probably cost the game — but true to his usual form, he wasn’t much for taking questions. Still, there is a PR lesson in his succinct, unemotional and deliberate answers.

Consider this snippet posted by the Boston Globe where a reporter asks a hypothetical question:

Reporter: “Would you do it again?”

Belichick: “You only get one chance.”

Hypothetical questions are enchanting because we instinctively desire to defend our reasoning — as if we explain it — they’ll all agree and understand. It rarely works out that way. Hypotheticals are also dangerous because the answers often lead to an equation where the variables might change at any given moment — or in this case on any given Sunday.

Think about the second and third order of effects of answering that question. If Belichick answered “no” then he’s admitted a mistake and if he answered “yes” he’s stubborn.

Sure maybe he can pitch it that he’s learned from his mistake or maybe he can point out it was a calculated risk since he made a very similar call in a game earlier this season against Tampa Bay that worked out in the Patriots’ favor. In either case, those rationalizations are exactly the point: they lead to another hypothetical question…and another…and another.

Sunday’s decision is not a good news story and the best thing the Pats can do is put this behind them and prepare for next weekend. That would be harder to achieve if the organization faced an enduring media distraction fueled by hypothetical questions.

If you enjoyed this post, you might also like:
Native Advertising’s Google Problem

Photo credit: WEBN-TV, Bill Belichick at the podium on Super Bowl XLIX media day, Flickr, (CC BY 2.0)

You may also like
If you want to get the best results out of PR, you 100% must put some effort into Twitter
5 point memo to PR about Twitter from a survey of 2,000 journalists (to get the best results from PR, you must put effort into Twitter)
The Basic Benefits and Drawbacks of Owned, Shared, Earned, and Paid Media
PR Coverage May have a Bigger Influence on SEO than Links 
Your Response to Business Reviews Might Count as Much as the Review Itself
Read previous post:
The Tao of Hip Hop's PR Revival
The Tao of Hip Hop’s PR Revival

Misunderstood. That was Howard Stern's pitch in a movie aimed at reinventing himself. But as far as celebrity PR makeovers go, a...