Sword and the Script

Conflict, confusion and finding your own damn social media advice



by Frank Strong

Some say a Facebook fan is worth $10.  Others say a fan is worth $0.  Still other say the value of a fan is falling.  It’s harder to get smaller than zero, but perhaps a better method of valuation is what an organization would pay for a fan.

In any case, any or all of these options are likely to leave the less daring more confused and conflicted over likes, shares, and soon perhaps wants.

What many want is sound advice, or perhaps an easy answer.  Preferably in the form of an iPhone app we can download and absorb through osmosis while sleeping with our phones under our pillows.  It’s a long winded way of saying, that at least in the short term, proven advice, is an unlikely social share.

“Not a day goes by that I don’t see conflicting information about the value of Facebook ‘Likes,’ the correlation between online conversations and buying behavior,” wrote Mark Schaefer in a post titled, Social Media, Conflicting Data, and the Search for Truth.  And so it is with social media advice.

He wrote that months ago, but a week or so ago, I watched another prominent speaker trash Klout at a conference – it’s worthless she said.  Really worthless?  There are more diplomatic word choices especially for PR professionals.  A few hours later, Mark took the stage an offered some pretty compelling examples of where Klout has been effective.  In fact I’d credit Mark and his writing with changing my view point on the platform:  it may not be a measure of influence, but it’s certainly an interesting marketing tool.

It might work for you.  But then again it might not.  The conflict continues.

A few weeks ago, I worked on analyzing data from a statistically significant survey conducted by a third-party research firm. Some of the results floored me.  For example, the fact that 27 percent of small- and mid-sized businesses (SMBs) reported focusing on building large followings – and that group was more inclined to say their approach was working by tangible measures, like sales.

John Jantsch, a partner in the study, wrote of the results on his blog Duct Tape Marketing, that, “The common social media wisdom of ‘more engagement over more numbers’ has some room to be challenged.” Indeed, the data is sound and it flies in the face of conventional wisdom. It’s given me pause too.

Advice, particularly based on experience can be useful, but the problem with advice is that it provides a perspective though the lenses of a particular world view.  Often that view is focused, but narrow — it’s an antonym for the panoramic.  A different perspective too can be useful, but only you can decide what advice to keep and what to set aside.

Pam Moore might have said it best in the text of a post with an inherently conflicting headline, when she wrote, “There is only one way to do social media and that is the way that works for you and your business.”

That’s right; we have to find our own damn social media advice.  Don’t be afraid to buck the trend:  listen, observe, research and then do what you think is best.

If you enjoyed this post, you might also like:
Social media: you get what you give 

Be Sociable, Share!

Posted In: Social Media
Tags: , ,

Be Sociable, Share!
Leave a Comment
7 comments
TaiGoodwin
TaiGoodwin

Just today I did a workshop for authors on how they can use social media. Instead of focusing on platforms and tools, I focused on being clear about what they wanted to accomplish: more credibility, to build a community for readers, research, connect to peers, create more awareness. My goal was to get them thinking about using the tools the best way that worked for them. Surprisingly it was a tough sell. I could have given them the standard this is how you use...but frankly you can google that and find answers by the dozen. What is harder to come by is the critical thinking and evaluation process that helps people determine what's going to get them the results they need and want.

Frank_Strong
Frank_Strong moderator

 @TaiGoodwin I think you are right Tai, it's almost like the ability to get nearly anything online instantly is washing away critical thinking. 

geoffliving
geoffliving

Agreed.  The issue really comes down to one way or no way, and that's not a realistic view of life. Imagine if everything was like this. We'd have many oppressed people in life, or at least many who felt bad about doing things differently.

Frank_Strong
Frank_Strong moderator

 @geoffliving You are right, Geoff, it's not realistic.  Even experts get it wrong -- just ask the weather-caster. 

Soulati | Hybrid PR
Soulati | Hybrid PR

Absolutely love this post and I have deduced much the same as the peeps you reference here. It's great to do what every counselor tells you but at the end of the day it's what works for your company. PS great Mobile website ! Am on iPhone 4S with no nav issues!

Latest blog post: How Not To Use Triberr